Modify Primary Key Using Index (Learning To Fly) February 27, 2014Posted by Richard Foote in 12c, Modify Primary Key Using Index, Oracle Indexes, Primary Key, Richard's Musings.
add a comment
One of the things I love about working with Oracle Database technologies is that there’s just so much one can learn. I make it an active goal of mine to try to learn something new at work each and every day, no matter how big or small. One of these days, I might blog about a presentation I put together a while ago on the common habits of highly successful DBAs (or technologists in general). One of these key habits I believe is the constant need to keep learning and to keep growing professionally.
One of the places I constantly turn to in order to learn something new is Jonathan Lewis’s Oracle Scratchpad blog. I doubt many folks who read my blog don’t already know what a fantastic source of information this is. Reading a recent posting of his on Modifying Primary Keys was one such moment where I went “wow, I didn’t know you could do that” !!
I previously blogged about the new 12c capability of having Multiple Indexes On The Same Column List and demonstrated how it was now possible to “quickly” swap the index on say a Primary Key constraint by pre-building a new index (say a Unique index to replace an existing Non-Unique index), then drop/disable the constraint and old index, make the new index visible and re-applying the PK constraint.
Well, as Jonathan described, there’s an easier alternative that doesn’t require so much stuffing around with the PK constraint.
I’m just going to setup the same demo as I used in the initial multiple indexes discussion where I have a Non-Unique index policing the PK constraint of a table:
SQL> create table ziggy (id number, name varchar2(30)) partition by range (id) (partition ziggy1 values less than (1000), partition ziggy2 values less than (2000), partition ziggy3 values less than (maxvalue)); Table created. SQL> insert into ziggy select rownum, 'DAVID BOWIE' from dual connect by level <=5000; 5000 rows created. SQL> commit; Commit complete. SQL> create index ziggy_id_i1 on ziggy(id); Index created. SQL> alter table ziggy add constraint ziggy_pk primary key(id); Table altered.
I then subsequently decide to replace the existing Non-Unique index policing the PK constraint with say a Unique Index instead. (Note the following also applies for Unique constraints as well). With 12c, I can pre-create another index with a different characteristic on the same column, I just have to initially make it Invisible:
SQL> create unique index ziggy_id_i2 on ziggy(id) invisible online; Index created.
Now comes the interesting bit (for me anyways). I can simply modify the PK or Unique Key constraint to use the new index with the USING INDEX clause:
SQL> alter table ziggy modify constraint ziggy_pk using index ziggy_id_i2; Table altered.
And then switch the visibility of the two indexes:
SQL> alter index ziggy_id_i1 invisible; Index altered. SQL> alter index ziggy_id_i2 visible; Index altered. SQL> drop index ziggy_id_i1 online; Index dropped.
Thereby changing the index policing the PK constraint without having to drop/disable the PK constraint in the process. I do have both indexes invisible for a brief period of time, so still exercise some caution, although the PK business rule is safe at all times without having to lock the table.
Obviously, if you wish to switch the index with one that uses a different column list (for example, if you wish to remove an unnecessary column from the policing index), then the indexes can simply be switched without having to alter their visibility attributes.
As Jonathan pointed out in his post, this capability dates back to later versions of 9i.
I wonder what I’ll learn tomorrow …
12c Enhanced Online Index DDL Operations (Lady Godiva’s Operation) February 17, 2014Posted by Richard Foote in 12c, Drop Index, Invisible Indexes, Online DDL, Oracle Indexes, Unusable Indexes.
1 comment so far
In my last couple of posts, I discussed how table partitions can be moved online since 12c, keeping all indexes in sync as part of the process.
12c also introduced enhancements to a number of index related DDL statements, removing blocking locks and making their use online and far less intrusive. The following commands now have a new ONLINE option:
DROP INDEX ONLINE
ALTER INDEX INVISIBLE/VISIBLE ONLINE
ALTER INDEX UNUSABLE ONLINE
So if we look at a little example (initially on 11g R2), where we create a table and associated index on the CODE column:
SQL> create table radiohead (id number, code number, name varchar2(30)); Table created. SQL> insert into radiohead select rownum, mod(rownum,1000), 'DAVID BOWIE' from dual connect by level <= 1000000; 1000000 rows created. SQL> commit; Commit complete. SQL> create index radiohead_code_i on radiohead(code); Index created.
If we now insert a new row in one session but not commit:
SQL> insert into radiohead values (1000001, 42, 'ZIGGY STARDUST'); 1 row created.
And then attempt any of the following DDL commands in another session:
SQL> drop index radiohead_code_i; drop index radiohead_code_i * ERROR at line 1: ORA-00054: resource busy and acquire with NOWAIT specified or timeout expired
SQL> alter index radiohead_code_i invisible; alter index radiohead_code_i invisible * ERROR at line 1: ORA-00054: resource busy and acquire with NOWAIT specified or timeout expired
SQL> alter index radiohead_code_i unusable; alter index radiohead_code_i unusable * ERROR at line 1: ORA-00054: resource busy and acquire with NOWAIT specified or timeout expired
They all get the well-known “ORA-00054: resource busy” error.
If on the other hand, one of these DDL statements is already running in a session:
SQL> alter index radiohead_code_i unusable;
All DML statements in other sessions will hang until the DDL completes:
SQL> insert into radiohead values (1000002, 42, 'THIN WHITE DUKE');
Once the index is finally made unusable:
SQL> alter index radiohead_code_i unusable; Index altered. SQL> select index_name, status from dba_indexes where index_name = 'RADIOHEAD_CODE_I'; INDEX_NAME STATUS ------------------------------ -------- RADIOHEAD_CODE_I UNUSABLE SQL> select segment_name, blocks, extents from dba_segments where segment_name = 'RADIOHEAD_CODE_I'; no rows selected
We can see not only is the index now in an unusable state but the index segment has been dropped (in 11g r2) as the storage associated with the unusable index is of no further use.
So these commands prior to the Oracle 12c Database previously had locking related issues.
If we now perform the same setup in 12c and again have an outstanding transaction in a session:
SQL> drop index radiohead_code_i online;
The Drop Index command doesn’t now get the Ora-00054: resource busy, but rather hangs until all prior transactions complete.
However, while the Drop Index command hangs, it doesn’t in turn lock out transactions within other sessions. In another session:
SQL> insert into radiohead values (1000002, 42, 'THIN WHITE DUKE'); 1 row created.
And in yet other session:
SQL> delete radiohead where id = 42; 1 row deleted. SQL> commit; Commit complete.
These all complete successfully. The Drop Index command itself will eventually complete successfully once all prior transaction have finished.
SQL> drop index radiohead_code_i online; Index dropped.
Another more subtle difference in behaviour with 12c. If there’s an existing transaction when you decide to make an index unusable:
SQL> insert into radiohead values (1000001, 42, 'ZIGGY STARDUST'); 1 row created.
SQL> alter index radiohead_code_i unusable online;
As in the previous demo, the alter index command will hang indefinitely until the previous transaction commits:
SQL> commit; Commit complete.1 1SQL> alter index radiohead_code_i unusable online; Index altered. SQL> select index_name, status from dba_indexes where index_name = 'RADIOHEAD_CODE_I'; INDEX_NAME STATUS ------------------------- -------- RADIOHEAD_CODE_I UNUSABLE SQL> select segment_name, blocks, extents from dba_segments where segment_name = 'RADIOHEAD_CODE_I'; SEGMENT_NAME BLOCKS EXTENTS ---------------- ---------- ---------- RADIOHEAD_CODE_I 2176 32
We note the index has eventually been made Unusable, however the segment has not now been dropped (as it was in the 11g R2 demo) due to the use of the ONLINE clause.
With the Oracle 12c Database, the locking implications and concurrency issues associated these index related DDL commands have been reduced with these new ONLINE options.